Merge "Fix distinguishing between stack-create and stack-update"
[apex-tripleo-heat-templates.git] / puppet / controller.yaml
index d966700..bf196d2 100644 (file)
@@ -1,22 +1,13 @@
-heat_template_version: 2015-10-15
+heat_template_version: 2016-04-08
 
 description: >
   OpenStack controller node configured by Puppet.
 
 parameters:
-  AdminEmail:
-    default: 'admin@example.com'
-    description: The email for the keystone admin account.
-    type: string
-    hidden: true
   AdminPassword:
     description: The password for the keystone admin account, used for monitoring, querying neutron etc.
     type: string
     hidden: true
-  AdminToken:
-    description: The keystone auth secret and db password.
-    type: string
-    hidden: true
   AodhApiVirtualIP:
     type: string
     default: ''
@@ -43,6 +34,12 @@ parameters:
     default: false
     description: Whether to store events in ceilometer.
     type: boolean
+  CeilometerMeterDispatcher:
+    default: 'database'
+    description: Dispatcher to process meter data
+    type: string
+    constraints:
+    - allowed_values: ['gnocchi', 'database']
   CinderApiVirtualIP:
     type: string
     default: ''
@@ -100,6 +97,11 @@ parameters:
     default: 0
     description: Number of workers for Cinder service.
     type: number
+  controllerExtraConfig:
+    default: {}
+    description: |
+      Deprecated. Use ControllerExtraConfig via parameter_defaults instead.
+    type: json
   ControllerExtraConfig:
     default: {}
     description: |
@@ -189,49 +191,24 @@ parameters:
     type: string
     constraints:
       - custom_constraint: nova.flavor
-  GlanceNotifierStrategy:
-    description: Strategy to use for Glance notification queue
-    type: string
-    default: noop
-  GlanceLogFile:
-    description: The filepath of the file to use for logging messages from Glance.
-    type: string
-    default: ''
-  GlancePassword:
-    description: The password for the glance service and db account, used by the glance services.
-    type: string
-    hidden: true
-  GlanceBackend:
-    default: swift
-    description: The short name of the Glance backend to use. Should be one
+  GnocchiBackend:
+    default: file
+    description: The short name of the Gnocchi backend to use. Should be one
       of swift, rbd, or file
     type: string
     constraints:
     - allowed_values: ['swift', 'file', 'rbd']
-  GlanceFilePcmkDevice:
-    default: ''
-    description: >
-      An exported storage device that should be mounted by Pacemaker
-      as Glance storage. Effective when GlanceFilePcmkManage is true.
+  GnocchiIndexerBackend:
+    default: 'mysql'
+    description: The short name of the Gnocchi indexer backend to use.
     type: string
-  GlanceFilePcmkFstype:
-    default: 'nfs'
-    description: >
-      Filesystem type for Pacemaker mount used as Glance storage.
-      Effective when GlanceFilePcmkManage is true.
+  GnocchiApiVirtualIP:
     type: string
-  GlanceFilePcmkManage:
-    default: false
-    description: >
-      Whether to make Glance file backend a mount managed by Pacemaker.
-      Effective when GlanceBackend is 'file'.
-    type: boolean
-  GlanceFilePcmkOptions:
     default: ''
-    description: >
-      Mount options for Pacemaker mount used as Glance storage.
-      Effective when GlanceFilePcmkManage is true.
+  GnocchiPassword:
+    description: The password for the gnocchi service and db account.
     type: string
+    hidden: true
   HAProxyStatsPassword:
     description: Password for HAProxy stats endpoint
     type: string
@@ -243,10 +220,6 @@ parameters:
     default: /dev/log
     description: Syslog address where HAproxy will send its log
     type: string
-  GlanceWorkers:
-    default: 0
-    description: Number of workers for Glance service.
-    type: number
   HeatPassword:
     description: The password for the Heat service and db account, used by the Heat services.
     type: string
@@ -295,43 +268,6 @@ parameters:
     type: string
     constraints:
       - custom_constraint: nova.keypair
-  KeystoneCACertificate:
-    default: ''
-    description: Keystone self-signed certificate authority certificate.
-    type: string
-  KeystoneEnableDBPurge:
-    default: true
-    description: |
-        Whether to create cron job for purging soft deleted rows in Keystone database.
-    type: boolean
-  KeystoneSigningCertificate:
-    default: ''
-    description: Keystone certificate for verifying token validity.
-    type: string
-  KeystoneSigningKey:
-    default: ''
-    description: Keystone key for signing tokens.
-    type: string
-    hidden: true
-  KeystoneSSLCertificate:
-    default: ''
-    description: Keystone certificate for verifying token validity.
-    type: string
-  KeystoneSSLCertificateKey:
-    default: ''
-    description: Keystone key for signing tokens.
-    type: string
-    hidden: true
-  KeystoneNotificationDriver:
-    description: Comma-separated list of Oslo notification drivers used by Keystone
-    default: ['messaging']
-    type: comma_delimited_list
-  KeystoneNotificationFormat:
-    description: The Keystone notification format
-    default: 'basic'
-    type: string
-    constraints:
-      - allowed_values: [ 'basic', 'cadf' ]
   KeystoneRegion:
     type: string
     default: 'regionOne'
@@ -348,10 +284,6 @@ parameters:
     default: false
     description: Whether IPtables rules should be purged before setting up the new ones.
     type: boolean
-  KeystoneWorkers:
-    default: 0
-    description: Number of workers for Keystone service.
-    type: number
   SaharaApiVirtualIP:
     type: string
     default: ''
@@ -711,24 +643,12 @@ parameters:
   HeatApiVirtualIPUri:
     type: string
     default: ''
-  GlanceApiVirtualIP:
-    type: string
-    default: ''
-  GlanceRegistryVirtualIP:
-    type: string
-    default: ''
   MysqlVirtualIP:
     type: string
     default: ''
   MysqlVirtualIPUri:
     type: string
     default: ''
-  KeystoneAdminApiVirtualIP:
-    type: string
-    default: ''
-  KeystonePublicApiVirtualIP:
-    type: string
-    default: ''
   NeutronApiVirtualIP:
     type: string
     default: ''
@@ -794,6 +714,12 @@ parameters:
     type: json
     default: {}
 
+parameter_groups:
+- label: deprecated
+  description: Do not use deprecated params, they will be removed.
+  parameters:
+  - controllerExtraConfig
+
 resources:
 
   Controller:
@@ -954,9 +880,7 @@ resources:
         bootstack_nodeid: {get_attr: [Controller, name]}
         ceilometer_workers: {get_param: CeilometerWorkers}
         cinder_workers: {get_param: CinderWorkers}
-        glance_workers: {get_param: GlanceWorkers}
         heat_workers: {get_param: HeatWorkers}
-        keystone_workers: {get_param: KeystoneWorkers}
         nova_workers: {get_param: NovaWorkers}
         neutron_workers: {get_param: NeutronWorkers}
         swift_workers: {get_param: SwiftWorkers}
@@ -988,9 +912,7 @@ resources:
         heat_enable_db_purge: {get_param: HeatEnableDBPurge}
         horizon_allowed_hosts: {get_param: HorizonAllowedHosts}
         horizon_secret: {get_param: HorizonSecret}
-        admin_email: {get_param: AdminEmail}
         admin_password: {get_param: AdminPassword}
-        admin_token: {get_param: AdminToken}
         neutron_public_interface_ip: {get_param: NeutronPublicInterfaceIP}
         debug: {get_param: Debug}
         cinder_enable_db_purge: {get_param: CinderEnableDBPurge}
@@ -1015,23 +937,6 @@ resources:
               - '@'
               - {get_param: MysqlVirtualIPUri}
               - '/cinder'
-        glance_port: {get_param: [EndpointMap, GlanceInternal, port]}
-        glance_password: {get_param: GlancePassword}
-        glance_backend: {get_param: GlanceBackend}
-        glance_file_pcmk_device: {get_param: GlanceFilePcmkDevice}
-        glance_file_pcmk_fstype: {get_param: GlanceFilePcmkFstype}
-        glance_file_pcmk_manage: {get_param: GlanceFilePcmkManage}
-        glance_file_pcmk_options: {get_param: GlanceFilePcmkOptions}
-        glance_notifier_strategy: {get_param: GlanceNotifierStrategy}
-        glance_log_file: {get_param: GlanceLogFile}
-        glance_dsn:
-          list_join:
-            - ''
-            - - 'mysql+pymysql://glance:'
-              - {get_param: GlancePassword}
-              - '@'
-              - {get_param: MysqlVirtualIPUri}
-              - '/glance'
         heat_password: {get_param: HeatPassword}
         heat_stack_domain_admin_password: {get_param: HeatStackDomainAdminPassword}
         heat_dsn:
@@ -1042,26 +947,8 @@ resources:
               - '@'
               - {get_param: MysqlVirtualIPUri}
               - '/heat'
-        keystone_ca_certificate: {get_param: KeystoneCACertificate}
-        keystone_signing_key: {get_param: KeystoneSigningKey}
-        keystone_signing_certificate: {get_param: KeystoneSigningCertificate}
-        keystone_ssl_certificate: {get_param: KeystoneSSLCertificate}
-        keystone_ssl_certificate_key: {get_param: KeystoneSSLCertificateKey}
-        keystone_notification_driver: {get_param: KeystoneNotificationDriver}
-        keystone_notification_format: {get_param: KeystoneNotificationFormat}
-        keystone_enable_db_purge: {get_param: KeystoneEnableDBPurge}
-        keystone_dsn:
-          list_join:
-            - ''
-            - - 'mysql+pymysql://keystone:'
-              - {get_param: AdminToken}
-              - '@'
-              - {get_param: MysqlVirtualIPUri}
-              - '/keystone'
         keystone_identity_uri: { get_param: [EndpointMap, KeystoneAdmin, uri_no_suffix] }
         keystone_auth_uri: {get_param: [EndpointMap, KeystoneInternal, uri] }
-        keystone_public_url: { get_param: [EndpointMap, KeystonePublic, uri_no_suffix] }
-        keystone_internal_url: { get_param: [EndpointMap, KeystoneInternal, uri_no_suffix] }
         keystone_ec2_uri: { get_param: [EndpointMap, KeystoneEC2, uri] }
         enable_fencing: {get_param: EnableFencing}
         enable_galera: {get_param: EnableGalera}
@@ -1175,6 +1062,10 @@ resources:
         ceilometer_password: {get_param: CeilometerPassword}
         ceilometer_store_events: {get_param: CeilometerStoreEvents}
         aodh_password: {get_param: AodhPassword}
+        ceilometer_meter_dispatcher: {get_param: CeilometerMeterDispatcher}
+        gnocchi_password: {get_param: GnocchiPassword}
+        gnocchi_backend: {get_param: GnocchiBackend}
+        gnocchi_indexer_backend: {get_param: GnocchiIndexerBackend}
         ceilometer_coordination_url:
           list_join:
             - ''
@@ -1191,6 +1082,15 @@ resources:
               - '@'
               - {get_param: MysqlVirtualIPUri}
               - '/ceilometer'
+        gnocchi_dsn:
+          list_join:
+            - ''
+            - - 'mysql+pymysql://gnocchi:'
+              - {get_param: GnocchiPassword}
+              - '@'
+              - {get_param: MysqlVirtualIPUri}
+              - '/gnocchi'
+        gnocchi_internal_url: {get_param: [EndpointMap, GnocchiInternal, uri]}
         snmpd_readonly_user_name: {get_param: SnmpdReadonlyUserName}
         snmpd_readonly_user_password: {get_param: SnmpdReadonlyUserPassword}
         nova_enable_db_purge: {get_param: NovaEnableDBPurge}
@@ -1260,7 +1160,6 @@ resources:
         glance_api_network: {get_attr: [NetIpMap, net_ip_map, {get_param: [ServiceNetMap, GlanceApiNetwork]}]}
         glance_registry_network: {get_attr: [NetIpMap, net_ip_map, {get_param: [ServiceNetMap, GlanceRegistryNetwork]}]}
         glance_api_servers: { get_param: [EndpointMap, GlanceInternal, uri]}
-        glance_registry_host: {get_param: GlanceRegistryVirtualIP}
         heat_api_network: {get_attr: [NetIpMap, net_ip_map, {get_param: [ServiceNetMap, HeatApiNetwork]}]}
         keystone_public_api_network: {get_attr: [NetIpMap, net_ip_map, {get_param: [ServiceNetMap, KeystonePublicApiNetwork]}]}
         keystone_admin_api_network: {get_attr: [NetIpMap, net_ip_map, {get_param: [ServiceNetMap, KeystoneAdminApiNetwork]}]}
@@ -1270,9 +1169,15 @@ resources:
         neutron_local_ip: {get_attr: [NetIpMap, net_ip_map, {get_param: [ServiceNetMap, NeutronTenantNetwork]}]}
         ceilometer_api_network: {get_attr: [NetIpMap, net_ip_map, {get_param: [ServiceNetMap, CeilometerApiNetwork]}]}
         aodh_api_network: {get_attr: [NetIpMap, net_ip_map, {get_param: [ServiceNetMap, AodhApiNetwork]}]}
+        gnocchi_api_network: {get_attr: [NetIpMap, net_ip_map, {get_param: [ServiceNetMap, GnocchiApiNetwork]}]}
         nova_api_network: {get_attr: [NetIpMap, net_ip_map, {get_param: [ServiceNetMap, NovaApiNetwork]}]}
         nova_metadata_network: {get_attr: [NetIpMap, net_ip_map, {get_param: [ServiceNetMap, NovaMetadataNetwork]}]}
         horizon_network: {get_attr: [NetIpMap, net_ip_map, {get_param: [ServiceNetMap, HorizonNetwork]}]}
+        horizon_subnet:
+          str_replace:
+            template: "['SUBNET']"
+            params:
+              SUBNET: {get_attr: [NetIpSubnetMap, net_ip_subnet_map, {get_param: [ServiceNetMap, HorizonNetwork]}]}
         rabbitmq_network: {get_attr: [NetIpMap, net_ip_map, {get_param: [ServiceNetMap, RabbitMqNetwork]}]}
         redis_network: {get_attr: [NetIpMap, net_ip_map, {get_param: [ServiceNetMap, RedisNetwork]}]}
         redis_password: {get_param: RedisPassword}
@@ -1319,11 +1224,15 @@ resources:
             - midonet_data #Optionally provided by AllNodesExtraConfig
             - neutron_opencontrail_data # Optionally provided by ControllerExtraConfigPre
             - neutron_plumgrid_data # Optionally provided by ControllerExtraConfigPre
+          merge_behavior: deeper
           datafiles:
             service_configs:
               mapped_data: {get_param: ServiceConfigSettings}
             controller_extraconfig:
-              mapped_data: {get_param: ControllerExtraConfig}
+              mapped_data:
+                map_merge:
+                  - {get_param: controllerExtraConfig}
+                  - {get_param: ControllerExtraConfig}
             extraconfig:
               mapped_data: {get_param: ExtraConfig}
             common:
@@ -1389,38 +1298,8 @@ resources:
                 cinder::db::mysql::password: {get_input: cinder_password}
 
                 # Glance
-                glance::api::bind_port: {get_input: glance_port}
                 glance::api::bind_host: {get_input: glance_api_network}
-                glance::api::auth_uri: {get_input: keystone_auth_uri}
-                glance::api::identity_uri: {get_input: keystone_identity_uri}
-                glance::api::registry_host: {get_input: glance_registry_host}
-                glance::api::keystone_password: {get_input: glance_password}
-                glance::api::debug: {get_input: debug}
-                glance::api::workers: {get_input: glance_workers}
-                glance_notifier_strategy: {get_input: glance_notifier_strategy}
-                glance_log_file: {get_input: glance_log_file}
-                glance_log_file: {get_input: glance_log_file}
-                glance::api::database_connection: {get_input: glance_dsn}
-                glance::registry::keystone_password: {get_input: glance_password}
-                glance::registry::database_connection: {get_input: glance_dsn}
                 glance::registry::bind_host: {get_input: glance_registry_network}
-                glance::registry::auth_uri: {get_input: keystone_auth_uri}
-                glance::registry::identity_uri: {get_input: keystone_identity_uri}
-                glance::registry::debug: {get_input: debug}
-                glance::backend::swift::swift_store_auth_address: {get_input: keystone_auth_uri}
-                glance::registry::workers: {get_input: glance_workers}
-                glance::backend::swift::swift_store_user: service:glance
-                glance::backend::swift::swift_store_key: {get_input: glance_password}
-                glance_backend: {get_input: glance_backend}
-                glance::db::mysql::password: {get_input: glance_password}
-                glance_file_pcmk_device: {get_input: glance_file_pcmk_device}
-                glance_file_pcmk_fstype: {get_input: glance_file_pcmk_fstype}
-                glance_file_pcmk_manage: {get_input: glance_file_pcmk_manage}
-                glance_file_pcmk_options: {get_input: glance_file_pcmk_options}
-                glance::notify::rabbitmq::rabbit_userid: {get_input: rabbit_username}
-                glance::notify::rabbitmq::rabbit_password: {get_input: rabbit_password}
-                glance::notify::rabbitmq::rabbit_use_ssl: {get_input: rabbit_client_use_ssl}
-
                 # Heat
                 heat_stack_domain_admin_password: {get_input: heat_stack_domain_admin_password}
                 heat::engine::heat_watch_server_url: {get_input: heat.watch_server_url}
@@ -1441,43 +1320,17 @@ resources:
                 heat::api_cloudwatch::workers: {get_input: heat_workers}
                 heat::api_cfn::bind_host: {get_input: heat_api_network}
                 heat::api_cfn::workers: {get_input: heat_workers}
+                heat::engine::num_engine_workers: {get_input: heat_workers}
                 heat::database_connection: {get_input: heat_dsn}
                 heat::debug: {get_input: debug}
                 heat::db::mysql::password: {get_input: heat_password}
                 heat_enable_db_purge: {get_input: heat_enable_db_purge}
                 heat::keystone::domain::domain_password: {get_input: heat_stack_domain_admin_password}
-
                 # Keystone
-                keystone::admin_token: {get_input: admin_token}
-                keystone::roles::admin::password: {get_input: admin_password}
-                keystone_ca_certificate: {get_input: keystone_ca_certificate}
-                keystone_signing_key: {get_input: keystone_signing_key}
-                keystone_signing_certificate: {get_input: keystone_signing_certificate}
-                keystone_ssl_certificate: {get_input: keystone_ssl_certificate}
-                keystone_ssl_certificate_key: {get_input: keystone_ssl_certificate_key}
-                keystone::database_connection: {get_input: keystone_dsn}
                 keystone::admin_bind_host: {get_input: keystone_admin_api_network}
                 keystone::public_bind_host: {get_input: keystone_public_api_network}
                 keystone::wsgi::apache::bind_host: {get_input: keystone_public_api_network}
                 keystone::wsgi::apache::admin_bind_host: {get_input: keystone_admin_api_network}
-                keystone::debug: {get_input: debug}
-                keystone::db::mysql::password: {get_input: admin_token}
-                keystone::rabbit_userid: {get_input: rabbit_username}
-                keystone::rabbit_password: {get_input: rabbit_password}
-                keystone::rabbit_use_ssl: {get_input: rabbit_client_use_ssl}
-                keystone::rabbit_port: {get_input: rabbit_client_port}
-                keystone::notification_driver: {get_input: keystone_notification_driver}
-                keystone::notification_format: {get_input: keystone_notification_format}
-                keystone::roles::admin::email: {get_input: admin_email}
-                keystone::roles::admin::password: {get_input: admin_password}
-                keystone::endpoint::public_url: {get_input: keystone_public_url}
-                keystone::endpoint::internal_url: {get_input: keystone_internal_url}
-                keystone::endpoint::admin_url: {get_input: keystone_identity_uri}
-                keystone::endpoint::region: {get_input: keystone_region}
-                keystone::admin_workers: {get_input: keystone_workers}
-                keystone::public_workers: {get_input: keystone_workers}
-                keystone_enable_db_purge: {get_input: keystone_enable_db_purge}
-                keystone::public_endpoint: {get_input: keystone_public_url}
                 # MongoDB
                 mongodb::server::bind_ip: {get_input: mongo_db_network}
                 mongodb::server::nojournal: {get_input: mongodb_no_journal}
@@ -1575,6 +1428,11 @@ resources:
                 ceilometer::agent::central::coordination_url: {get_input: ceilometer_coordination_url}
                 ceilometer::agent::notification::store_events: {get_input: ceilometer_store_events}
                 ceilometer::db::mysql::password: {get_input: ceilometer_password}
+                ceilometer::collector::meter_dispatcher: {get_input: ceilometer_meter_dispatcher}
+                ceilometer::dispatcher::gnocchi::url: {get_input: gnocchi_internal_url }
+                ceilometer::dispatcher::gnocchi::filter_project: 'service'
+                ceilometer::dispatcher::gnocchi::archive_policy: 'low'
+                ceilometer::dispatcher::gnocchi::resources_definition_file: 'gnocchi_resources.yaml'
                 snmpd_readonly_user_name: {get_input: snmpd_readonly_user_name}
                 snmpd_readonly_user_password: {get_input: snmpd_readonly_user_password}
 
@@ -1596,6 +1454,22 @@ resources:
                 # for a migration path from ceilometer-alarm to aodh, we use the same database & coordination
                 aodh::evaluator::coordination_url: {get_input: ceilometer_coordination_url}
 
+                # Gnocchi
+                gnocchi_backend: {get_input: gnocchi_backend}
+                gnocchi_indexer_backend: {get_input: gnocchi_indexer_backend}
+                gnocchi_mysql_conn_string: {get_input: gnocchi_dsn}
+                gnocchi::debug: {get_input: debug}
+                gnocchi::wsgi::apache::ssl: false
+                gnocchi::wsgi::apache::bind_host: {get_input: gnocchi_api_network}
+                gnocchi::api::service_name: 'httpd'
+                gnocchi::api::host: {get_input: gnocchi_api_network}
+                gnocchi::api::keystone_password: {get_input: gnocchi_password}
+                gnocchi::api::keystone_auth_uri: {get_input: keystone_auth_uri}
+                gnocchi::api::keystone_identity_uri: {get_input: keystone_identity_uri}
+                gnocchi::db::mysql::password: {get_input: gnocchi_password}
+                gnocchi::storage::swift::swift_authurl: {get_input: keystone_auth_uri}
+                gnocchi::storage::swift::swift_key: {get_input: gnocchi_password}
+
                 # Nova
                 nova::rabbit_userid: {get_input: rabbit_username}
                 nova::rabbit_password: {get_input: rabbit_password}
@@ -1627,6 +1501,7 @@ resources:
                 nova_enable_db_purge: {get_input: nova_enable_db_purge}
 
                 # Horizon
+                apache::mod::remoteip::proxy_ips: {get_input: horizon_subnet}
                 apache::ip: {get_input: horizon_network}
                 horizon::allowed_hosts: {get_input: horizon_allowed_hosts}
                 horizon::django_debug: {get_input: debug}
@@ -1758,12 +1633,12 @@ outputs:
       str_replace:
         template: |
           PRIMARYIP PRIMARYHOST.DOMAIN PRIMARYHOST
-          EXTERNALIP EXTERNALHOST
-          INTERNAL_APIIP INTERNAL_APIHOST
-          STORAGEIP STORAGEHOST
-          STORAGE_MGMTIP STORAGE_MGMTHOST
-          TENANTIP TENANTHOST
-          MANAGEMENTIP MANAGEMENTHOST
+          EXTERNALIP EXTERNALHOST.DOMAIN EXTERNALHOST
+          INTERNAL_APIIP INTERNAL_APIHOST.DOMAIN INTERNAL_APIHOST
+          STORAGEIP STORAGEHOST.DOMAIN STORAGEHOST
+          STORAGE_MGMTIP STORAGE_MGMTHOST.DOMAIN STORAGE_MGMTHOST
+          TENANTIP TENANTHOST.DOMAIN TENANTHOST
+          MANAGEMENTIP MANAGEMENTHOST.DOMAIN MANAGEMENTHOST
         params:
           PRIMARYIP: {get_attr: [NetIpMap, net_ip_map, {get_param: [ServiceNetMap, ControllerHostnameResolveNetwork]}]}
           DOMAIN: {get_param: CloudDomain}
@@ -1771,37 +1646,37 @@ outputs:
           EXTERNALIP: {get_attr: [ExternalPort, ip_address]}
           EXTERNALHOST:
             list_join:
-            - '-'
+            - '.'
             - - {get_attr: [Controller, name]}
               - external
           INTERNAL_APIIP: {get_attr: [InternalApiPort, ip_address]}
           INTERNAL_APIHOST:
             list_join:
-            - '-'
+            - '.'
             - - {get_attr: [Controller, name]}
               - internalapi
           STORAGEIP: {get_attr: [StoragePort, ip_address]}
           STORAGEHOST:
             list_join:
-            - '-'
+            - '.'
             - - {get_attr: [Controller, name]}
               - storage
           STORAGE_MGMTIP: {get_attr: [StorageMgmtPort, ip_address]}
           STORAGE_MGMTHOST:
             list_join:
-            - '-'
+            - '.'
             - - {get_attr: [Controller, name]}
               - storagemgmt
           TENANTIP: {get_attr: [TenantPort, ip_address]}
           TENANTHOST:
             list_join:
-            - '-'
+            - '.'
             - - {get_attr: [Controller, name]}
               - tenant
           MANAGEMENTIP: {get_attr: [ManagementPort, ip_address]}
           MANAGEMENTHOST:
             list_join:
-            - '-'
+            - '.'
             - - {get_attr: [Controller, name]}
               - management
   nova_server_resource: